rank all songs from TCATK

This is a special forum created for discussion of Elton John's new album "The Captain and The Kid" which is destined to be a classic!
EltonCroatiaFan
Step on the thin ice lightly...
Joined: 31 Jan 2006, 03:09

04 Nov 2006, 21:09 #1

This is overall ranking from hercules message board, so I am interested will the result be different here:
1. And The house Fell Down (215)
2. Blues Never Fade Away (191)
3. The Captain And The Kid (179)
4. The Bridge (151)
5. Tinderbox (140)
6. I Must Have lost It On The Wind (12Image
7. Postcards From Richard Nixon (120)
8. Just Like noah's Ark (110)
9. Old 67 (101)
10. NYC (96)

And this is my ranking:
Blues Never Fade Away
And The House Fell Down
The Captain And The Kid
The Bridge
I Must Have Lost It On The Wind
Postcards From Richard Nixon
Old 67
Tinderbox
Just Like Noah's Ark
NYC
Reply

jcdavies
Back then, I was handsome...
Joined: 19 Aug 2006, 23:09

05 Nov 2006, 12:13 #2

1.Blues never fade away
2.The Bridge
3. I must have lost it on the wind
4.Tinderbox
5.And the House fell down
6.Captain and the Kid
7.NYC
8.Postcards from Richard Nixon
9.Old 67
10.Noah's Ark
Sorry, the bottom 4 prevent this from being a classic.
Reply

The Fox
And lovers leap off burning buildings...
Joined: 09 Jun 2003, 08:23

06 Nov 2006, 03:28 #3

'And the House Fell Down'
'Tinderbox'
'Postcards For Richard Nixon'
'Blues Never Fade Away
'Wouldn't Have You Any Other Way (NYC)'
'The Captain and The Kid'
'The Bridge'
'I Must Have Lost it On The Wind'
'Old '67'
'Just Like Noah's Ark'
"A facinating cross of sharp as a whip and tougher than an Ox"
Reply

ThisSongHasNoTitle78
Hello, baby hello...
Joined: 19 Jan 2006, 06:39

06 Nov 2006, 06:38 #4

1."Blues Never Fade Away"
2."And The House Fell Down"(yes, I've had a change of heart)
3."Just Like Noah's Ark"
4."The Bridge"
5."Postcards From Richard Nixon"
6."I Wouldn't Have You Any Other Way"
7."Tiiiiiiiiinderbox"
8."I Must Have Lost In On The Wind"
9."Captain And The Kid"
10."Old '67"
Reply

pseaman.e
Hello, baby hello...
Joined: 15 Feb 2006, 00:28

06 Nov 2006, 16:10 #5

1. And The House Fell Down
2. Old 67
3. The Captain And The Kid
4. The Bridge
5. NYC
6. Postcards From Richard Nixon
7. I Must Have Lost It On The Wind
8. Tinderbox
9. Just Like Noah's Ark
10. Blues Never Fade Away
Reply

crazywater
They must have the whole thing planned...
Joined: 18 Jul 2001, 21:54

06 Nov 2006, 20:11 #6

Ok, here's a poll for us...click the image.

Image

"...if we all believe in the things you believe you're seeing..." EJ/BT '76The Crazy Water Community




"...if we all believe in the things you believe you're seeing..."
EJ/BT '76

Elton John: The Crazy Water Community


Elton John News Blog
Reply

ThisSongHasNoTitle78
Hello, baby hello...
Joined: 19 Jan 2006, 06:39

06 Nov 2006, 21:11 #7

I'm surprised to see "Just Like Noah's Ark" scoring some points; I thought I was the only one who saw the potential in that one.
Reply

BiteUrLip
Step on the thin ice lightly...
Joined: 16 Jun 2006, 20:05

08 Nov 2006, 17:20 #8

Quote:
I'm surprised to see "Just Like Noah's Ark" scoring some points; I thought I was the only one who saw the potential in that one.
That really reveals that some fans like more his rock songs than ballads. Although it received one of the lowest average grades (around 3.5 while many others had over 4) from TC&TK polls it still looks like to be many fan's favourite from the album.
I myself like years 1972-1976 the most because there are all of his funniest rock/pop songs. But despite that I prefer more ballads from 21st century Elton.
Image
Reply

HonkyCat
I\'ve seen that movie too...
Joined: 14 Sep 2006, 17:37

09 Nov 2006, 01:40 #9

Here's my rankings. And in the spirit of this board of late - I can't see how any one could possibly have any other opinion other than the one I outline here!
1. I Must Have Lost it On The Wind
2. The Captain and the Kid
3. I Wouldn't Have You Any Other Way
4. Old 67
5. Tinderbox
6. And the House Fell Down
7. Just Like Noah's Ark
8. Blues Never Fade Away
9. Postcards From Richard Nixon
10. The Bridge
Reply

EltonCroatiaFan
Step on the thin ice lightly...
Joined: 31 Jan 2006, 03:09

10 Nov 2006, 20:40 #10

COME ON YOU LAZY CW MEMEBERS.... MOVE YOUR LAZY A-SSES AND RANK TCATK Image
Reply